7 min read

Don’t Fear the Beeper

Generative AI content is currently aesthetically pretty bad. But what if one day it became very good? Would that spell disaster for the arts?
Don’t Fear the Beeper
An assemblage of cartoon robots performing and attending a space-age ballet. Image cropped from the 1928 CalTech yearbook.

There is a genre of Star Trek episode I have come to heartily despise. The specifics vary from show to show, but the broad-strokes premise is that the crew arrives at a planet that initially seems idyllic: close-knit communities living in harmony with one another in a landscape of bucolic abundance, frequently with an emphasis on how beautiful and fit and hearty all the residents are. But over the course of the episode, the horrifying truth comes out: This seeming utopia sits atop a pile of corpses — they practice eugenics and unsentimentally murder any newborn children who don’t meet their standards of perfection.

The logic here is transparent: It’s an attempt to rebut eugenicist thinking by taking on its strongest version — even if eugenics worked the way its proponents think it does, these episodes argue, it still wouldn’t be worth it because of the indefensible moral costs that it requires. But there’s a subtle danger here. Many eugenicists are quite open about the reproductive coercion and murder their ideal societies entail; they’ve simply decided that the people they don’t think should live and reproduce don’t deserve to live and reproduce and have hardened their hearts to the resulting horrors. Some even pride themselves on their ruthlessness: They value the society they imagine so much and have developed their inner toughness such that they can stomach the actions that they believe are necessary to force the world to that place. Showing a eugenicist pseudo-utopia that requires moral horrors to maintain isn’t a rebuttal from the eugenicist point of view, merely a confirmation that anti-eugenicists aren’t tough enough to do what the eugenicists believe needs to be done. A full rebuttal requires not only exposing the moral horror of the idea, but also driving home that eugenics doesn’t work — it’s bunk science, and anyone who believes its promises is deluding themselves. In leaving that latter work undone, I worry that these episodes reinforce the false notion that we could breed ubermenschen if only we abandoned our morals.

Heaven help me, I think I’m now going to write a structurally similar argument here.